Original Comic Art: What It Is, What It Is Worth and How to Protect It
READ MORE
August 10, 2026PROTECT YOUR MAGIC: THE GATHERING CARDS.
INSURE YOUR PASSION.
PROTECT THE MAGIC WITH MAGIC CARDS INSURANCE
Perhaps it's a set of limited-edition Magic: The Gathering sets, premium Commander sets, or cross over releases like Final Fantasy; whatever the case may be, your card is more than just a hobby, it's a high value asset. Comicsure insurance gives you peace of mind in knowing that your treasured Magic cards are protected against the unexpected
Our policies protect your cards from theft, accidental damage, fire, flooding, and loss during transit; so every graded, slabbed, or raw MTG single is insured at its full market value. From everyday Standard staples to prized Reserved List collectibles, keep your collection secure with protection designed for players who truly value their cards.
FOR COLLECTORS BY COLLECTORS
At Comicsure we recognise the cultural and financial weight of your collection, you cards carry a valuable story and legacy.
We appreciate the nuance between a gem and a well-loved deck that's seen hundreds of tournaments. Our tailored and flexible cover ensure that you have the best suited insurance for you and your collection.
INSURE YOUR MAGIC CARDS STAY MAGICAL
You won't have to worry about the risk in losing out on all the time and dedication that went into building your collection. Comicsure makes it so you feel confident that everything from base rookies and sticker autos to low-numbered parallels is properly valued and comprehensively insured.
The Magic: The Gathering market is constantly shifting, with prices influenced by factors ranging from competitive play, reprints, and even bans. As values move over time, it’s important that your cover keeps pace. Our specialist policies are built to respond to those changes, helping ensure your collection remains properly protected; whether it includes high-value Reserved List pieces, graded vintage cards, or modern tournament staples. From fire and theft to accidental damage or loss while travelling to events, Comicsure protects both the financial investment and the personal significance behind your cards.
WHAT WE CAN DO FOR YOU
We understand the unique needs of Magic card collectors. Our specialised insurance provides complete protection for your valuable collection.
ALL CARDS COVERED
From high-end chase cards to bulk commons, we cover all types of Magic cards regardless of value.
WORLDWIDE PROTECTION
Your Magic cards are protected anywhere in the world - at home, gaming conventions, trade shows, or while travelling internationally.
LOSS & THEFT
Full coverage against loss, theft, and mysterious disappearance. Your collection is protected in any situation.
DAMAGE COVERAGE
Protection against accidental damage, water damage, fire, and other unforeseen incidents that could harm your cards.
MARKET VALUE
Claims are settled at current market value, ensuring you receive fair compensation based on today's prices.
INSTANT COVERAGE
Get covered immediately after purchase. No waiting periods, no lengthy approval process. Simple and fast.
WHY CHOOSE COMICSURE FOR YOUR MAGIC CARDS?
Outside of purely collectible value, Magic cards can hold sentimental, cultural and even artistic importance. Whether you own iconic Reserved List cards, vintage singles, or carefully curated grade pieces, every Magic collection tells a different story. At Comicsure, we specialise in protecting that story with insurance specifically designed for collectors.
We aren't general insurers looking from the outside in, we actively collect and play Magic. From long-term collectibility to grading and reprints, we understand how value really works. This insight allows us to offer cover that reflects the value of your cards within the Magic market, and beyond a generic price tag. And from one set of collectors to another, here at Comicsure, we are committed to ensuring your collection and its value are protected.
Comicsure's Magic cover can be tailored to your specific needs. Whether your cards are locked away in a display, or travelling with you to tournaments and trade shows, we'll make sure they stay properly protected from the unexpected.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
We’ll collaborate with you to create an accurate, collector-centered valuation of your cards. By providing receipts, expert appraisals, or up-to-date market information, our specialists ensure your collection is covered at a fair and current value.
Absolutely! Even modest collections can contain unexpected value. Individual rares, mythics, promotional printings, foil variants, and graded singles can be costly to replace if they are lost or damaged. Specialist Magic card insurance, such as Comicsure, ensures players and collectors at every level have the right protection in place, giving you the confidence to keep building decks and collections alike.
Your Magic cards can remain covered while they're being shipped or taken to events. Specialist trading card insurance can include cover for cards in transit, offering reassurance when you post or trade valuable items.
Yes - in the case of damage or loss, we will offer fair replacement or compensation based on your needs. We understand how distressing a situation like this may be and ensure clear communication, care and understanding throughout the process.
Of course! whether you're headed to Grand Prix, CommandFests, game expos or local conventions, our portable property protection covers your Magic cards as long as they're handled responsibly and stored securely during travel.
Yes! Your magic cards books are covered anywhere in the world, including conventions, comic shows, trade events, and while travelling. This is one of the key benefits of specialist collector insurance over standard home insurance.
Yes - at Comicsure, our cover adapts alongside your evolving price changes, ensuring your collection still receives the best protection.
Absolutely! Comicsure ensures flexible cover that can be adjusted as your Magic collection changes. Our team can guide you through adding newly acquired cards, removing those you’ve sold, and revising totals so your policy keeps pace with the way you actually buy, sell, and play.
Look for an insurer that understands collectibles. The best trading card insurance comes from providers who specialise in hobbies and offer fair valuations - like Comicsure, which was built by collectors for collectors.
The cost of Magic cards insurance depends on the total value of your collection, how it’s stored, and whether cards are graded or raw. Specialist insurers like Comicsure offer flexible options tailored to your collection’s size and value.